Peer Responses
Week 1: The Lottery
Brandon,
The fact that the villagers are so committed to tradition they're wary to change the small detail of the black box is a direct reflection on how important tradition is to them. You did a great job of pointing that out. I also agree that this story was attempting to shine a light on how ridiculous some traditions are but because we aren't far removed from the situation its hard for us to see how barbaric they are. I think your essay was well organized and easy to read and your thoughts were original. with so many people commenting on the same short story there will obviously be an overlap in interpretation but I haven't seen anyone else propose your analysis. One of the great things about stories like this is that it can mean something different to everyone who reads it but there is no wrong or right answer.
Ivan,
I like the point you made in the second paragraph about how our previous understanding of words lead to us assuming their meaning in other contexts, the author uses this and flips it around causing a 'plot twist' near the end of the story. the best plots twists are predictable but still hidden so its possible for the reader to see it coming. I also like the parallel you drew between the story and historical events happening at the time when the story was written. I definitaly believe the events of world war 2 influenced the nature of the story.
Week 2: Blood Child
Kelly,
Your essay was very easy to read and I thought you flowed from thought to thought pretty seamlessly. you also chose a great section of text, i only wish that you would've sad more about Gan standing up to T’Gatoi, it felt like right as the essay was getting really good it was over. I know you reached 400 words but that doesn't mean you have to stop there. I thought it was interesting that T’Gatoi claims that Gan shouldn't be concerned with 'adult things' yet expects him to take on a huge adult burden at the same time. you defiantly help me think about this story a different way which is always good. Keep up the good work.
Ivan,
I liked how you incorporated another book with a similar theme into your analysis. When I was reading the second sentence of you text it was a little hard for me to understand what you were trying to say, I think it could have been worded better. If you took your time you could improve this a lot. I can tell you were kind of rushing or at least it seems that way based on how some words are either spelled incorrectly or auto correct made them something they were not meant to be. You would have caught a lot of those little mistakes with just a quick read through before you post. I know this class isn't really about grammar but I get easily distracted by that kind of thing. Overall I think you chose a very good line of text and explained yourself well. Also, I liked how you drew a parallel between the text and the historical context behind it. Good work!
Week 3: Black Box
Brandon,
I learned so much about the author from your essay and I thought all of your information was well organized and understood. I'm also very glad you included the story behind the format of Back Box. Now that I've read this it does seem just like a series of tweets. I don't have any huge corrections, your writing is good and I think you completed this assignment correctly. I think may you could've written more but if you're over 400 then that's not a real correction. I was just hoping the essay would go on longer than it did.
Overall, great essay, This is the first authorial research essay I've seen this term and I think it sets a good example.
Shaen,
I enjoyed your essay, but there are a few things I would change. your first sentence is a run on, this may have been an accident but I thought it was a little distracting. Also you have a selling error in the first sentence but its the only one so it didn't take away from the story. You said something about how her designated mate is the black box but I didn't get that impression from the text, I wish you included what line explains this. Other than these minor changes, I didn't really understand which parts were research so maybe if you added a little parenthesis to identify the source of certain thoughts every time. I saw you did it but as you continued your conversation I got confused. My last note is that I think you could've written more about this subject, maybe an average sized paragraph for each citation and a comparison and then you're personal thoughts. Overall you wrote a good essay but I definably think with some minor fixes it could be great.
Week 5: The Semplica Girl Diaries
Shaen,
Good job on this essay, I liked how you opened with a brief summary and its not horribly long but gives the reader a good idea of the story even if they hadn't of read it. The only thing I would change would be your first line when you describe the setting you said, " some would say the near but not so far future" to me this sounds redundant and it could've been a typing error. However when taking into account the rest of your essay it doesn't seem to matter up. This small error makes little to know difference. Your analysis of the text is very thoughtful and easy to understand. I also appreciated how you didn't just use a block quote to make your essay longer. This makes the words you do have more meaningful. I think you've really have a good understanding on how to write a crux essay. Keep up the good work.
Kelly,
Good job on your research. I liked how used a direct quote from the author and related it to the story. I think George Saunders is a very creative writer and it was fun being able to see what his life is really like. I see that you dedicated most of the text to the authors upbringing and early life before he began writing, and while this isn't bad I just with you would have written more about how he is now and how the Semplica Girl diaries relates to his current life. I also did an authorial research essay and I'm very glad I've learned more about him and I hope you feel the same.
Week 6 : The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas
No peer reviews
Week 7: The Lathe of Heaven
Hey Kelly,
I thought this was a good crux. You had plenty of evidence from the text to support your theme and I thought your quote was appropriate. I'm not sure why but I don't see Dr. Haber of as much of a villain as he is. To me he is more complicated than that. Obviously he made some huge mistakes and he is very arrogant and self serving but his semi good intentions lead me to believe that he isn't all evil. Though based on the other essays I've read I can see I'm alone in this opinion. I also liked how near the end you helped draw a parallel between 'The Ones who Walk away from Omelas" and "The Lathe of Heaven" since they were written by the same author. And your last point about how all the characters represented a different demographic from "Omelas", that just blew my mind I hadn't even thought about it that way. Well done.
Hey Meredith,
I liked your essay, I learned a lot about the author and I'm impressed you were able to fit so much information concisely into one min-essay. I can tell by reading your essay that you have a natural talent for writing. Your sentences have a natural flow to them. I liked how you started with a brief summary of her life and then went deeper in the following paragraphs. Even though I know this is a mini-essay, it seemed like your whole paper was a summary and I just wish there were more details. I also liked the quote you have on her writing. It united both pieces and makes it evident they were written by the same person and you thoroughly explained why to the reader. Overall, good job!
Week 8: The Lathe of Heaven
Hi Caitlyn,
I loved your essay. I find this sort of topic fascinating and I think you did a great job of explaining the subject matter. I can tell by reading that you were genuinely interested and it made it more fun to read. The only thing I would suggest would to draw a parallel between your research and The Lathe of Heaven. You talked about it in the beginning but after hearing all of the cool theories I wish you would have found some way to tie the two together and wrap it up nicely. I also thought you had good research your thoughts flowed nicely together. Very nice work!
Carmen,
I liked how you pulled philosophy into your essay, I used this quote for a crux last week but I mainly focused on the beginning portion and you looked deeper into the different meanings behind it. While I agree with most of your argument, I don't believe Dr. Haber cared as much about improving the world but more about being a savior or improving his life. If he really cared about humanity he would not have made the decisions that he did. I think your essay was very well organized and to the point. I never felt lost, you're very good at explaining your thought process in writing. You in every element that is supposed to be there in a crux essay and that's great but at some points it seemed filling in the blanks. Simply changing the wording of introductory sentences would make your essay seem like an assignment. And I know this is an assignment I'm just saying.
Comments
Post a Comment