The Value of Human Life


Great works of science fiction hold a mirror up to society, usually in a dramatized hypothetical way. Throughout all our readings this term, there is a underlying theme, what is the true value of human life and what (or who) are people willing to sacrifice for their own happiness. The characters in these stories dont realize how evil their actions can come across much like how we have been desensitized to injustice.

In The Lottery, a single citizen is chosen at random and sacrificed for the sake of tradition. However, this isn’t reveled until the end of the story. Initially the reader assumes ‘the lottery’ is some sort of prize that everyone wants. All the townsfolk enter the square nonchalant about the fact that one of them will die. After Mrs. Hutchinson is selected, people who were once her friends or family turn on her and stone her to death. This leaves the reader asking, why? And the answer is tradition and mob mentality. Its explained through dialog that this lottery as been taking place since before and of the villagers can remember and the thought of no longer participating is abhorrent to nearly all of the citizens. This story proves that people will go along with anything to prevent going against the grain. The only protester is Mrs. Hutchinson herself who can find no mercy in her neighbors. These people are willing to sacrifice their fiend simply because theyre told to. No one cares that their murdering a member of society and are enjoying themselves while they stone her.

The Semplica Girl Diaries illustrates the mistreatment of immigrants and servants. George Saunders a self-proclaimed family man is struggling to make ends meet financially. He is always wishing to be rich and be able to give his daughters whatever they desire. The theme of human neglect is an undertone the author glazes over, Georges struggle is in the forefront of the story at all times. Some people may not even notice it.  It’s first evident when George goes to the Torrins house and is introduced to their landscapers who are both named Karl. While this could be a coincidence, I belive that Mr. Torrins does not care to learn their real names, so he gave them one very ‘white’ name they share. This demonstrates how immigrants aren’t treated like real people and they cannot say anything about it because they need to keep their jobs. Suddenly, George wins the lottery and splurges on gifts for his family and a set of Semplica girls. The Semplica girls are strings of human girls who are strung across the lawn and represent wealth. These real people are being used as décor. This theme is somewhat ironic because George appears to be an immigrant himself. He uses broken English in his journal which implies English is not his first language or he wasn’t given a proper education. George wastes all of his money in attempt to make his girls happy and eventually, all he has left are the Semplica girls. One of his daughters recognizes the mistreatment of the girls and sets them free leaving George with nothing once again.

The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas is about a utopian society that relies on the torcher of a child to keep their society perfect. The author begins the story by describing Omelas. They seem defensive and say things like ‘you don’t belive me?’ hinting to a secret that’s yet to be revealed. You learn later in the text that to keep order in Omelas, a sacrifice had to be made. A child is kept in a cage at all times in constant torment. You can’t speak to the child or show it any compassion or understanding. There doesn’t seem to be any logical prof that this child has any correlation to life in Omelas but everyone believes this so instead of attempting to help the child, they walk away from Omelas all together hoping that this will relive the guilt they feel.

In The Lathe of Heaven George Orr can control the real world with his dreams. This ability is manipulated by his therapist, Dr. Haber who strongly believes that everyone I less importaint than him. This power proves to be dangerous when he decides to solve over population and indirectly kills 6 million people. This story shows hoe people can become extremely violent when given immense power. George is very much aware of the changes the Doctor is making but is so passive that he refuses to take control over his own life. Heather, George’s love interest in the story, also witnesses the destruction being done but is unable to help George in any way. Dr. Haber’s disregard for human life leads to so many lives lost but George remains a bystander and instead feels directly responsible since he was an instrument in the murders.

In all these stories, human life is either traded for something (safety, popularity) or disregarded so what do these stories tell us about our society. Many of the characters know whats happening is wrong and chose to do nothing about it. In the lottery, as Mrs. Hutchinson is struggling to bargain with her own life, a member of the crowd questions this tradition but says nothing. In the Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas, every citizen sees the injustice in the city but choses to leave instead of attempting to make a change, and face adversity head on. In The Lathe of Heaven, both George and Heather see the destruction being done by Dr. Haber and make no real decision to stop him.  The only exception is in the Semplica girl diaries, one of George’s daughters sees the inhumanity and changes it by setting the girls free.

As I said before, science fiction is used to shed light on society and attempt to show people how crazy their actions are when they are removed from the situation. If you look at the news, there’s a new disaster every day. Its such a common occurrence that we’ve been trained to not be bothered. People are constantly dying due to school shootings or terror attacks and a lot of us act like the people in The Lottery, grateful it’s not us, glad were safe for now. This is not humane. We should be trying to change injustice in society not gloss over or ignore it like the characters in The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas. And we should learn to act out if it’s the right thing to do like George’s daughter in The Semplica Girl diaries. Being a bystander does nothing for the victims, it’s always better to say something than to remain silent.

"I swore never to be silent whenever and wherever human beings endure suffering and humiliation. We must always take sides. Neutrality helps the oppressor, never the victim. Silence encourages the tormentor, never the tormented." - Elie Wiesel

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Reflective Essay