Conversations

Week 1: The Lottery

When the story describes the black box where all of the names are kept, its a hint at how long the lottery has been going on. The box is tattered and needs replacing. We know its older than 77 years, because the old man says this is his seventy seventh time drawing and still claims 'There has always been a lottery'.  I thought it was interesting how light hearted this event seemed at first, I assumed the prize from this lottery would be good based on everyone's attitude, sure people seemed nervous but not distraught. Mrs. Hutchison was even making jokes. It was only the old man who recognized the cruelty and importance of the lottery, saying that getting rid of it would be like going back to living in caves.

Once its decided that Mrs. Hutchinson has been chosen, her apparent friends from before show absolutely no mercy and violently stone her. I wish I knew the events prior to the start of the lottery that would cause it to be necessary. Overall, this story reflects how people respond to tradition even after its become barbaric and stupid to an outside audience. Maybe at one point in time it made sense to brutally murder one of your neighbors but in this context it certainly does not, however no one in the situation is able to see it.

Week 2: Blood Child

I defiantly agree with you that Gan becomes more likable as the story progresses. He goes from a helpless sheep obeying those in authority to taking his life into his own hands and choosing to sacrifice himself to save his sister from pain. I don't see this story as a love or coming of age story like the author describes in the afterward paragraphs though. To me it tells the tale of humans finding themselves enslaved to some sort of alien race and I don't believe any of the aliens care about the humans at all. 

Based on the fact that T’Gatoi hesitates or doesn't directly answer when Gan asks important questions, I get the feeling that she is just using him. Also the fact that she didn't care who she implanted her egg into and just needed to do it tonight makes me think that her 'family' is  only there because they are useful to her. Although I didn't care for T’Gatoi, I actually really likes Gan and thought he was a good person. He didn't follow blindly but still chose to make a hard decision for the good of his siblings. He knew if he took his own life that his sister would wind up having to carry the worm children and while his other brother was far more selfish and would do anything to make sure it wasn't him, he refused to stoop that low. 

Week 3: Black Box

When I started reading this story, I was very confused just like everyone else. After I got used to it, I really liked the structure of the story. It made sense and almost felt like I was the woman in it.

The black box that the story is named after refers to a collection of information in the form of recordings and pictures that the protagonist had gathered throughout her mission. I'm not  exactly sure what her mission is but the story mentions that she can become a hero if she executes it correctly and we can assume its for her country because the story mentions patriotism several times. I'm guessing that this woman works for a spy agency that uses "beauties", or attractive woman, to get information from terrorists or men threatening the country. The reason this works is because most beautiful woman are viewed as objects and they're usually not thought of as smart or even useful for anything other than sex in this story.

The story mentions that you're supposed to use this to your advantage and stay unnoticed, keeping a low profile so you don't pose any threat. I really liked this story because it seems probable. In the next decade humans are going to start having technology implanted into them and using it for something like this seems interesting. 

Week 5: The Semplica Girl Diaries

The Semplica girl's diaries tells the story of a close knit and loving family who are struggling to get  by financially. I found several themes in this story. First of all, after the family puts Semplica Girl's on their lawn and they begin to gain popularity in the community, the children begin to rebel and one of them sets the girls free. While maybe the Semplica Girl's made the family more popular, they slowly ruined their closeness and I believe they would have been better off without them. In the beginning while none of the children seem thrilled with their financial situation they are all accepting of it and they all love their parents. I also recognized a theme of mistreatment of immigrants, first at Lesli's house when both the yard workers names are Karl. While this could be a coincidence, I'm assuming the Torrins simply doesn't want to take the time to learn their real names.

 Again with the Semplica Girls themselves, I understood they are real people strung up on the front lawn which is totally a violation of human rights. As far as the first person perspective I thought it was very useful for story telling. Based on 'Dad's' broken english you can tell he's either an immigrant himself and english is not his first language or he doesn't have a high level of education leading to their financial troubles. I the beginning he always seems hopeful to the future but he knows he's lying to himself. After he gets drunk at the Torrins he says that he hates work and how rich people look down on him. Part of him knows he will never rise to the upper class but he will not admit it to himself until the very end of the story when he realizes that no matter how much he has there will always be someone who has more than him. 

Week 6: The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas

No Conversation

Week 7: The Lathe of Heaven

The Lathe of heaven is a story mostly based on setting. The main character George changes reality itself with his dreams and his therapist takes advantage of this to "solve" the worlds problems and also improve his personal life. As far as world building, George himself rebuilds the world around his through the story. I think its amazing how George has so much power yet he's always taken advantage of by other. It seems that he never gets to control whats happens. I just cant imagine having so much power but not being able to utilize it. Sometimes when reading the story, its hard to tell whats real or if any of it is real at all.
As the story progresses, you learn more about each character. At first you think Haber, George's therapist, has good intentions like when he changes the weather. But after he kills a million people and causes an alien invasion, you start to realize that he is not only self serving but also a firm believer in "the end justifying the means." He doesn't care if 6 million innocent people die if it solves the over population problem. This kind of person should not be given so much power. 

Week 8: The Lathe of Heaven

I think Caitlin made a great point about how George's character grows and evolves over time, he goes from viewing his ability as a curse to seeing it as an opportunity to fix the world. Dr. Haber however starts out very pretentious and self serving and when he's given power transforms a usually harmless trait into something destructive.  In many stories and in reality, experience and time help improve characters making them wiser and broadening their perspective. Yet in Dr.Haber's case, his experience made him much more dangerous and he doesn't seem to learn much from his mistakes. We learn early on that he does not value all human life, he views all people as opportunities to further himself. And what Juliette said about how no one can remember how the world was before its changed by George's dream is very terrifying. Kind of reminds me of the Mandela Effect if anyone knows what that is. Scary!

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Reflective Essay

The Value of Human Life